Great review Bonnie....
This was our 3rd RSSC cruise, and what you said about the first night in the Compass Rose is exactly what we said. We were really concerned after the first night as it seemed that the service was just "off" a bit. We weren't sure if it was because it was a larger ship (our first to RSSC cruises were both on the PG), or what it was that was different. It seemed as if there were a lot of new crew members, which was later confirmed by one of our waiters. But after the first night, we sat in Danilo's section each night, and everything began to click, just as we hoped it would.
This was our first Holiday cruise as well, and we weren't sure what to expect, but we were more than happy with the entire cruise, we would definitely do it again.
Now we need to plan the next one....I'm kind of leaning toward the 10 day PG on 12/12/07.
DanZ