There are quite a few of us who pre/post cruised last year in NYC. We did twice.
Our favorite restaurant is Felidia's which is Midtown. For a NYC "Foodie" place, the Chef's Tasting dinner is very reasonable and the food excellent. We did 21 Club and La Grenouille, which were also very good. We also ate at a seafood restaurant in Time Square we enjoyed.
Where are you staying for your precruise?