Don, my fomrer SIL is a Sea Dream fan, she loves it, but she has not been on ships that have those wonderful balconies. Since I seem to require them, I keep egging her on toward the ships I like. It is really just a personal decision. I also did not find Silversea staff to be at all standoffish, ate with the Staff Captain and he even followed me out to the appropriate area in the middle of dinner for a smoke! I loved the Shadow on my one cruise.