Good advice, Peter, I thought so too. But I like the funky side of Florida--to me, Florida is like that (my mum wintered near Dayton for 15 years, and that area is definitely funky.) Little dockside seafood bars with picnic tables, that sort of thing.

So, I'm going to book a place like that, probably. The Tropi Rock Resort gets good reviews on tripadvisor. It's close to where we stayed last time, so we know at least one nice restaurant within walking distance. It's also cheap. Not deluxe, for sure, but they have a dog!