We did our first onboard open booking on the Mariner last fall (old policy). My husband has never wanted to do this sort of thing before, but because of the terms it seemed like a low risk idea - and then we've booked our second cruise less than one month later.
If the new policy had been in place, I don't think we would have done either, so to us the change isn't a positive. I'm sorry that they feel the need to impliment a change, especially since it is now something we probably won't use.