My feeling is she will get to select another cruise and the contest was based on "availability".
I did check on that cruise and it is waitlisted.
My guess of what really happened here is that Travelocity put her on "availabilty" waitlsit which is different from a regular passenger wait list. a much lower priority. There is no booking number and the regular reservations dont have anything to do with that.
Then Travelocity just never followed up keeping her informed of the status of that cruise. They did it and forgot it. RSSC would have contacted Travelocity if it cleared but it has not cleared.
If they had checked before Christmas and seen how full this sailing was they could have told Sue at that time to "pick another date".
Had this sailing cleared at the 30 days out then everything would have been fine. The problem is that the cruise is full.
Just my guess.