IMHO Guillou runs the best ship and keeps both the pax and the crew happy. He trained Dag and Dag trained Broomhall(Diamond). It was a shame to lose Broomhall when Diamond departed, but maybe he'll be back when they get a new ship. The others are capable Captains, but the only other one that interfaces well with the pax is Knut. It's a delicate balancing act to run a good ship where the crew has high morale, the ship is run well and the pax are happy. As a retired career Navy guy, I think Guillou does it best.