Priscilla, we have been in one of the vista suites with the non private shared verandahs twice on the Silver Whisper. The first time in 527 and the last time in a handicapped cabin in 535 (almost twice the size at well over 400 sq ft) I might add that we were waitlisted the last time and since the handicapped cabin is held back in case that it is needed it was released to us within 60 days of sailing.
Here is my take on it. Normally I would say, go for the private verandah. However on a very port intensive cruise, where you don't have a lot of sea days to really enjoy the verandah, I feel that for us it is not worth the additional $900. Many times there is nobody else out there.
Now there is no table and chairs out there, but we just drag two of the chairs out from our room along with our bucket of champagne and just sit out there and enjoy watching the world go by. Without the dividers you can see soooo much more as well. Again, I found that it was rare that anybody was ever out there.
Only downsides that I could see were that you could not keep you door open at night, since it was not private and you also had to be careful to make sure that you had the curtains pulled or sheers if you were changing. We found that to be minor. Another downside is that there are only 7 Vista suites on deck 5 along with the additional 2 handicapped cabins, so they are tough to get. They are very popular.
We were fortunate to get another one (525) for our upcoming Caribbean cruise in November.
Let me know if you have any other questions. I would be happy to help.