I agree with Wendy and Dena. Definitely try both restaurants. We read less than stellar reports about LeGrill before our PG cruise, but we ended up dining there twice (you are only supposed to go once per sailing, but we begged our way back in). We just loved it. It is better to be seated at a table out by the railing rather than a central table - you get a better breeze. My only (minor) complaint about LeGrill is the tables are small, and fitting all the drinks, bread, etc. can be very tight if 4 are dining together.

Crystal, I know you are going to LOVE the PG!