My two cents canadian...
I still like dressing for dinner. Even in Orlando, we have restaurants that require coat and tie. Of course, there are also many nice restaurants here that our tourist casual. They are different experiences. I cannot imagine going to Victoria & Albert's without coat and tie, just wouldn't seem right. Same thing with cruising; I still think the formal nights are a reminder of the classic days at sea (of course, days long before I was cruising).
As for packing, I think Radisson is doing the wrong thing with only one formal night. Two nights make more sense. To match the officers, men would dress black out and white back. Not much more weight for the white dinner jacket. As Olivia said, women's formal are quite often lighter than informal or casual clothes. For men, the weight isn't that much more than informal.
Of course, we have cruise lines that respond to all types of potential customers; even those that want casual dress. Windjammer and NCL come to mind. I have loved my CCC cruises on Radisson, too.
Now my concerns. For the most part, I have met only pleasant, courteous, polite guests on my Radisson cruises. That is certainly one thing that has made my experiences wonderful. After all, we can't select the other passengers ourselves. Although clothes don't make one necessarily more polite; not following a dress code is a sign of disrespect for rules and ones fellow passengers. I think that Radisson could end up with a lot of "drunken slobs" if all inclusive, casual, and cheap. Of course, this would not be the case if ALL cruiselines go "casual" at the same time while Radisson retained their price point.
On the Mariner and Voyager, La Verandah is casual on all evenings. There are no reservations for La Verandah. Even if you decide at the last minute that you don't want to dress for the evening, you can go to La Verandah. A long leisurely dinner, flambe for dessert, and a stroll by the pool or on the track are all doable in casual clothes any night of the cruise. Definitely a reasonable option to dining ensuite. Unfortunately, not doable on Navigator or Diamond.
I think it is also important to retain informal nights. Again, probably because I equate clean and proper dress with civilization. I sometimes feel out of place in compass rose on casual nights when I am not wearing a jacket; the restauant doesn't seem as special.
For our upcoming transatlantic, I will haul tux and dinner jacket over to Europe. With no snorkling equipment, will have plenty of room and weight allowance. For PG, no problem leaving formal behind; after all, I understand it to be a totally different experience. For ROAR, there is a restaurant I am looking at in Cape Twon that requires a coat and tie; so, I will probably take one coat just in case. Each trip is different.
I guess what I am trying to say is that some cruises would be a disappointment without formal nights. Especially, the longer cruises with many sea days. It would just seem strange.
For shorter European itineraries, I guess one formal night does provide for the chance for those of us that want to dress up (especially formal nights upon departure from Venice with masks) while minimizing the negative impact on those that choose not to dress for the evening. I am just very fearful that the experience that some have reported on some cruises, inlcuding the all inclusive CCC cruises, not become the norm.