I enjoy a variety of dress codes when I am on a cruise, and hope they keep them, except perhaps in places like Alaska, because the other packing takes up more room. Sometimes on formal night I go down a little early and wait for my daughter in one of the lounges near the entrance to the dining room just to watch. I have never seen anyone with a miserable look on their face, in fact, the people always seem quite festive!
As for packing weight, my formal clothes weigh less than the outfits I wear on informal nights.
And for what men like these days, I hear that men's fashion is on the way again to the upscale side.
I won't comment on the burkha comment, as I don't want to test Richard's flameproof suit!