That "Male Burqua" comment cracked me up! I've got to remember that one - will give you credit, Richard.
The Tux thing has to be a throwback to "POSH" Atlantic crossings when there was nothing to do all day but play shuffleboard and wait(and dress) for dinner. The formal thing is not for cruising, particularly when there is a port every day. Also really dumb on a short cruise with one formal night - bring along the Tux with all accoutremnts for 3 hours use - give us a break! I vote for a mix of informal/CCC nights. By the way, on the NYC-Montreal trip which had this mix - it was clear that the ladies dressed up irrespective of what the guys wore. Unless some are into the "Bond, James Bond",thing let's not require formal after dinner. In no case should gentlemen be admitted into the dining room with completely inappropriate dress (shorts & T shirt etc.) nor should ladies.