Margo, definitely get a group together to do this, it is much more fun that way. Jes, my younger daughter (21 at the time) did not enjoy it on the Diamond when it was just the two of us. They paid way more attention to her than she wanted, putting the mike to her lips, etc. for singing, and she can't sing. When we did it on the Black Sea, the tables were larger, and people got their nerve up a lot more. I'll never forget the pictures Karen posted with Mark and his band of singers with the napkins on their heads! The menu on the Diamond was set. You just took what they gave you and didn't eat if you didn't want it. Funny, last trip on the Navigator the Maitre'd made a special point of telling me this was "not" like the Diamond (they had added music by then). Seems he must have been replaced, and since this was such a popular thing on the Diamond, it is good!