Ah..I'm the complete opposite. I wouldn't even CONSIDER doing the Western route again, after doing it in December. There's something less than comforting about getting off a 6 star luxury ship and stepping into complete abject poverty. They're looking at you with distaste....and you don't blame them. And in Cozumel "My turn now lady, my turn now lady" did wear thin. Also, it's less than comforting being greeted by armed military personnel, who hang out by the ship all day. Guns, poverty, and seeing the destruction left behind by recent hurricanes, it was all too much for me.
St. Bart's is too rich for my liking, Guatamala and Costa Maya too poor. I felt very comfortable in St. Maarten, Tortola, Turks & Caicos....
But, to each his own, I'm just surprised I'm the only one who disliked the Western itinerary, several people on my Voyager cruise were echoing the same sentiments.