Hi Ron -- We have also done both and do prefer the Western Caribbean. In Cozumel we booked a private snorkeling tour to get us away from the crowds -- it worked well.
Which ever choice you make, you'll have a wonderful time!
🚢 Cruise with your favorite Keene Luxury Travel Staff Member! 💰 5% KLT Reward plus Shipboard Credit available (amount varies per voyage)! 💲 Offering Enhanced KLT Rewards on voyages hosted by Ngaire & Clay!