We used Red October and were pleased. We know folks who used the ship's private tour once on board and we knew others who booked the ship's group tours. While "value" is personal, I can state that everyone I spoke with, including ourselves, was happy with whichever alternative he or she chose. If cost is a factor, Red October or a Group Tour may be a better option for you. With a Group Tour you do not have the opportunity to custom to your interests. I believe the costs were comparable. However, folks were pleased with the group tours. So, don't stress, whatever you choose should be fine.