Sue,
Hubby and I were on the PG October 2005. Loved it! The best vacation ever! We stayed at the Beachcomber when we arrived for one night and stayed at the Radisson Plaza with a day room before our late evening flight home.
I liked the Beachcomber the best! It was very tropical. We had a standard room that was nice. The pool and view is outstanding!
The Radisson Plaza is OK and has a nice pool. The room we had there was bigger and nicer than the Beachcomber, but it had more of a "hotel" feeling than a resort feeling in my opinion.
You really can't go wrong with either, but I would choose the Beachcomber! You really know you're on a tropical vacation when you stay there. Also, it has a really neat lagoon where you can practice your snorkeling!
Enjoy your trip!
Babs