Greg, I'm one of those who've "seamlessly" gone over to SS and find it every bit as nice a line as Regent, but I've only been on two cruises with them, compared to many, many more on Regent. My first cruise was on the Shadow (Asia), and the other was on the Whisper (Middle-East), so I have not cruised on the Cloud, which is smaller. I had way too critical an eye for my first cruise with them, being a Regent fan, but by the end, honestly, I couldn't tell the differences between the lines. I think Ngaire is spot on with comparing cabin size (well, the ship for that matter) to Diamond vis a vis the Cloud. On the larger ships, cabins are virtually identical in size to the bigger Regent ships, as I have looked into this in the past.
As for itinerary, first Norway cruise on the Navigator is up there in my top three, if not the best, for intinerary. We had pretty much perfect weather except in Svaalbard or whatever that "grey" port is way far from Norway. If you love scenery, and have good weather, this cruise will be unmatched. My second cruise there, not so lucky with the weather, but I still loved it, because of the BK group aboard. But cold and sometimes rainy can squelch the spirit compared to a warm and sunny day in any port!
"One (or two of them) difference is...." (not sure if so on the Cloud), there are two alternate restaurants, and one has a surcharge (Champagne, charge is mostly for fancy wines). Terraza is wonderful on Shadow and Whisper, and no charge.
On my two SS cruises, I have hauled home a complimentary bottle of Dom Perignon champagne, which is wasted on me, but too nice a treat to leave behind.
I liked the more international make-up of the guest list, especially on my first cruise (the second was a BK group cruise). It was in Asia, and we had only 38% of Americans, and a lively mix of many other nationalities.
Dress, as I remember follows about the same codes as Regent currently does, three of them. I like to dress abit for dinner (informal my favorite), but could do without formal. On formal nights, I would say same ratio of suits to tuxes. I don't have a clue why people say SS is more formal (or in particular "stuffy"), as I didn't find that at all. With all the Aussies we had aboard, quite the contrary!
The entertainment seemed different to me, especially my first cruise when we attended a lot of the shows. No productions shows, but some of the best entertainers of various types that I have enjoyed on any cruise. I remember our CD (a lovely lady) was opera trained, but switched over to more modern singing in same show.
One "negative difference" that you will just have to suck up is no free internet or any of the perks we have that I love on Regent. That is just not a reason to avoid a line entirely, to me.
Even free excursions if all the other things are perfect with itnerary, price, and time.
I just know you will enjoy it, if you like Regent!