I would try the Noordam. You already know going in that it will be a different experience than the Radisson or Silversea but from my experience on HA, I found it to be very pleasant.
I sailed on Holland America after being spoiled by Radisson and we still had a very good time. I say go for it!
🚢 Cruise with your favorite Keene Luxury Travel Staff Member! 💰 5% KLT Reward plus Shipboard Credit available (amount varies per voyage)! 💲 Offering Enhanced KLT Rewards on voyages hosted by Ngaire & Clay!