Kim, there's not one bad choice in front of you, for sure! But after 2 BK safari trips, and one other time in SA to get on a Regent ship that included a second stay at BH (and tour of La Residence on one trip). I'd be hard pressed to tell you not to go to Cape Town.
My first visit was with one of my daughters (ROAR 1), the second with her younger sister (ROAR 2). On both occasions, we spent 2-3 days in Cape Town, and I'll never forget the experience. It's a beautiful city, you would be on the go most of the day to really experience it, and not wandering around the pretty town of Franken........ (La Residence, however you spell it).
There is much that Cape Town has to offer to learn about this country and the history of apartheid. In the US we were so cut off from SA during this period of history, and I for one wanted to learn more, as I was so young back then, more connected with my own little world than the one around me.
We did so much from Cape Town on the first visit (all arranged by Ngaire), including winery tours, Cape Point (?) and the museum in the center city, gondola ride to the top of Table Mountain, the Green Market, and wonderful restaurants. With my younger daughter, we did an independent tour of the Township areas, including the shanties, that I will never ever forget.
At least plan to see Cape Town some time in the future, as I'm sure, like Marcie said, you and Alice will become "addicted" and return some day!