Welcome, Count Florida! You are across the hall from us, so the neighborhood will be in good hands.
We're not planning an overnight in Israel at this point, but a touring company that I can recommend based on my experience in planning for TUT is Guided Tours Israel --
www.guidedtoursisrael.com. The person I dealt with was Alon, and he was very accommodating and great source of information. Since we didn't actually get to Israel on TUT I can't vouch for the on-the-ground service, but I'm betting it would be very good.