lapeter, thanks for the review! I think the things that fell short on Cloud will be rectified when you are on the Whisper, newer ship (I still nit-picked with some maintneance issues) with cabins almost identical to the Navigato and Voyager. Like your wife, as time went on, I liked it better and better. We didn't have room service issues, fortunately. We are lucky to have many good choices when booking a cruise for the future.