We've had three butlers. The first one needed a little more training, plus was overwhelmed by the number of cabins he was assigned (many travel agents onboard, having parties). The second one wrung his hands in angst because we simply didn't have very much for him to do. The last one was probably the best (Glen on Navigator); he was calm and efficient.
Those bar snacks would be too tempting; the limited canapes that come in the afternoon are just about right. Two bites and they are gone.
I really like the pillow request thing; we were coming very close to cornering the market on pillows last month before I taught our little stewardess how to feel for the feathers that I did NOT want. She heard "four" instead of "foam".