Greg,
Do both. In Oct. 08, Regent offered an overnight to Petra and evening in Wadi Rum. It was a magnificent magical day/night.
The earliest you can get to Petra, the better as it gets crowded. There is a lot of walking at Petra. The excursion should have the 3 walker symbol. I wouldn't say strenuous, but long. I think we walked 5 miles that day at Petra.
The Wadi Rum area is beautiful (We had a full moon that night). The drive through the desert was in old Toyota trucks with seats in the back. It wasn't the easiest to get into and we needed assistance. The Bedouin dinner was really good, but you will be sitting on the ground... covered with carpets. You will sleep well that night.... but it is not to be missed.