Thanks for all the feedback!

The Westin has been sold out since I began looking almost a year ago and many high end tour companies stay there so when I saw it pop up as available today I thought it might be special. Today I've read mixed reviews on tripadvisor, flyertalk etc., especially about the non-renovated rooms and not so great service.

The Hyatt looks the best for the rooms, our personal aesthetic, and more, but the location isn't terribly convenient, nor do there seem to be many, if any, walkable restaurants. We are adventurous eaters and would definitely be venturing out for Japanese food. I reserved a balcony room there a year ago there, overlooking the gardens, but is is very expensive - a year ago, before the meltdown, I would have gone with the splurge, but now am looking for something more reasonable. Given that it is prime autumn color time rooms in Kyoto over the weekend are scarce.

The Granvia does not look terribly inspiring, but you can't beat the convenience of the location as far as airport and touring logistics. Also there are plenty of interesting restaurants nearby or easily accessible by a few minutes subway ride. I was able to reserve a room on the club floor there so that is probably what we will decide on.

I wish there were a clear choice! Over dinner Brad commented that he's never seen me ruminate over a hotel selection like this one!


Leslie