Karen, I wish you'd go with us (and others here) on the Oct. 15 '05 Diamond. A back to back would enable you to see so many of the ports you're inquiring about (also includes 2 full days in Monte Carlo!!)
I've actually been to most of them but feel they are so worthwhile that I'm thrilled to go again.
Of the ones you mentioned, I've been to Barcelona, Monte Carlo, Portofino, Sorrento, Livorno (Florence), Rome, Venice and Naxos (Taormina). It's tough for me to pick a favorite but I'd have to go with some of the obvious....Rome, Venice, Barcelona with close seconds being Sorrento & Taormina. I could visit all of these again and again!