We have been to both Capri and the Amalfi coast. Both are beautiful places. Capri is easy to get to own your own (high speed ferry from the port). There is no need to go with a group and you may be better off on your own as the island can be quite crowded with day trippers. We found Almalfi less congested and more interesting in the diversity of attractions. Endorse the earlier recommendation to go to Almafi with your own car and driver (don't need a separate guide) rather than on a bus tour. You will see far more of this beautiful area and avoid the long Italian lunch to take full advantage of your limited time. If faced with a choice, I'd also go to Almalfi.