Maria, I can't help you with Regent tours because we've just done our own thing. I Love the Amalfi Coast (we did it with 2 other couples with private guide). It is magnificent.
Capri is very commercialized and $$$ now. I've been several times but won't go anymore. My favorite of the islands is Ischia...it is like Capri probably was 40 years ago. Very Charming !! It is easy to get around on hydrofoil on your own should you decide to do your own thing.