Jeanine - great review! Glad the eggs benedict were up to snuff. How were they with the mimosas a la balcony? :D Re-entry is tough!
We also really enjoyed the shark & ray feeding at Bora Bora. We cleaned out Ramon's supply of Shark Boy shirts, hats, anything with that lovely logo. The Lagoon Discovery was also a wonderful excursion. We had just the opposite weather, though - winds up in Bora Bora and very calm in Mo'orea. We decided to skip the Tahiti tour, too and are glad we did.
As for ideas for the next one .. there are just so many good choices it's hard to go wrong. My husband's favorite (retired engineer who also controls packing duties) was the Panama Canal itinerary. Ours was on Voyager immediately following the end of the World Cruise so a really interesting passenger mix added to the whole experience. Second favorite of his is our first one on Mariner: 10 days Nice to Venice in October and then the Baltics on Voyager. I have trouble identifying any "favorites" as all of them (save one) have been great in their own way. The only one we didn't get into was a short (5 day/4 night San Juan to San Juan itinerary in March) Carribean trip. Not enough time to get into it and weather cut the port stops short. Particularly memorable trips were the first leg of South America and the 8 day Mariner China cruise last year. Hope that gives you a few ideas.
Best wishes on your 37th anniversary and your birthday. Here's to many more happy and healthy celebrations! Cheers, Anne