MPBear,
We've gone into the dining room (on Mariner and Navigator) with a party of 10 and been accomdated without reservations.
Thoughout our last voyage on the Navigator we (Crusinfanatic and her husband and some non-LCT'ers) had a party of eight (and once 10, I think) every night and we lucked out having the Captian's table almost all of the 9 nights of our cruise with it's beautiful arrangement of roses and some really great wait staff. We had the same situation on the Mariner as well.