My wife and I have been on the Windsurf 3 times and loved it. We switched to RSSC a year ago, but would go back.

Never have been on their smaller ships - - - but the 300 passenger Windsurf was a comfortable size. Note: it was the smallest ship we have sailed on ---. Best part about the Windsurf were the suites. They knocked the wall out of a floor of cabins and replaced the bed in one with a couch. End result was a double cabin with TWO FULL BATHS !!! That was a real treat. The price wasn't outrageous.

Hope this helps. If you've already sailed with the line, you know their strengths. There was sufficient crew and I don't remember having to wait in lines. Nights were very quiet. Not much to do.

Jim