I'd vote for the 10 day cruise--mainly because it's 10 days, but also because it doesn't go to Venice. I suppose you do need to visit Venice at least once, though, if you've never been there. We ended up a cruise there a few months ago and found it extremely expensive among other negative things. We had been there twice before and liked it, but this time we had several bad experiences with water taxi drivers (attempts at gross overcharging on two occasions, an attempted purse snatching and a number of surly waiters, etc in Venice. Now that I mention it, the only pleasant person we ran into the whole time we were there (three days) was the concierge in the hotel. It was though the whole city was angry--really odd. The airport was a zoo. We were there in early May but it was still very, very crowded and hot. Overall a bad experience--I won't be going back. But we loved Croatia on that trip--especially Hvar.