I think you will enjoy Tikehau.
It is quite different and like stepping back in time. Tiny place but rather delightful. The setting is beautiful and you arrive by boat from the airport (a landing strip and one small "building"). The rooms are very nice. It is a little quiet but if you enjoy snorkelling and really chilling out this is quite a change from the main society islands. When we were there small children from the local village danced and sang for us while we ate dinner. Quite different from the normal shows because these really were just kids not professionals. We found it charming.
It has been about four years since I went and it was brand new at that time. I am sure it has changed a little since then.
Good to try something new anyway, I think you will be happy with this choice.