Yeah, when something looks too good to be true, it usually is!
Don,
Typically one way tickets are outrageously expensive. What I have done if I only need a one way is to book the segment I need and book a "return" ( which I'll never use) on the cheapest date I can find. It might be higher that the $425 you were getting with airfare.com but it certainly will not be anything near $2,848!!
Good luck!