Crystal, I was reading Cruise Critic way back in 2001 when Renaissance went bankrupt and people were stranded like you mentioned happened with Windjammer. I wish my memory were better, but I seem to recall that there was lots of discussion about getting refunds from travel insurance or credit card companies. I don't recall that there was a 60 day limit on the credit card company protection but would not be surprised it that varies from company to company and/or over the years. I've tried doing a search on Cruise Critic but I don't think they keep threads that old.
I also wonder about splitting the charge between two different cards. I think the only way you might get some solid information would be to call and speak with a service representative from each credit card company.