Found it. I'm going to post it, just for y'all's general amusement. <a href='http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb008' target='_blank'><img src='http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/11/11_4_124v.gif' border=0></a>
Now, understand that when I wrote this I had only cruised on Royal Carribbean and Celebrity, and had faced these situations on both cruises. So I truly was curious what she had to say. Unfortunately, that turned out to be nothing!
<a href='http://www.smileycentral.com/?partner=ZSzeb008' target='_blank'><img src='http://smileys.smileycentral.com/cat/4/4_6_201.gif' border=0></a>
Anyway, here's the letter I wrote:
"Dear Miss Manners,
I have recently discovered the wonderful world of cruise vacations. There is much to love about cruising, however, I have found myself vexed by a couple of issues that seem to be ubiquitous among most cruise lines: the "dress code paradox," and the "chair hog dilemma."
The first has to do with the rules aboard most ships (at least within the mid to elite range) dictating how one should dress in the dining room. A typical dress code might read: "On informal nights, men are requested to wear a jacket and tie, while women may wear a suit or dress. For the formal nights evening gowns or cocktail dresses for women, and a tuxedo or dress suit for men are preferred." Often, the rules state that passengers are expected to maintain the dress code throughout the evening, for the shows, in the lounges, etc. This appears to be a venerated cruise tradition, stemming from the old, grand days of passage by ship.
The problem is that, apparently, some passengers do not feel compelled to follow these guidelines, and this is offensive to some other passengers who prefer not to dine with people in jeans while they themselves are in their finery. Some cruise lines are stricter than others, and will actually turn away improperly dressed diners, but they sometimes seem loathe to displease a paying customer, so you do occasionally end up seeing tank tops and flip flops seated next to tuxes and ball gowns. And then begin the wars: the jeans crowd argues that they paid their fare and should be entitled to dress as they please on their vacation, and the "fashion police" should mind their own business and stop letting others' clothes choices spoil their good time. The tux crowd maintains that the rules are there to set an ambiance for passengers’ enjoyment, and if they don’t want to follow them, they should eat at the casual buffet (almost always available on another deck) or choose another type of vacation where no such rules apply, rather than subject others to their "I’ll do as I please" mentality. Being the peacemaker that I am, I would find it quite uncomfortable to be at a table in which such animosity was flowing. Was there something I could say to smooth the waters?
The second occurs when passengers arise early in the morning, stake out the best lounge chairs at the pool by placing belongings on them, then disappear for hours. This leaves the rest of us sun worshippers with no place to sit at the pool, relegated to inferior locations in the shade or, worse, squatting on the hard deck.
The cruise lines usually have a policy disallowing "saving" lounges for longer than 20 minutes, and sometimes post signs to that effect, but this seems to have little impact. I have seen 8 to 10 lounges, all tied together by towels and each bearing one item (a flip on one, a flop on another), unoccupied until 2 pm, at which time a family of 4 or 5 arrives, spends 45 minutes, then departs, leaving the chairs still reserved. Crewmembers seem unwilling to ruffle any feathers by actually removing the belongings, no matter how long they’ve been there. I have seen some brave souls remove the items and sit in the chair, only to be confronted later by a ranting, raving passenger, furious that their chair was "stolen." I’ve heard of confrontations actually coming to fisticuffs!
Miss Manners, I would value your opinion on these matters, and perhaps some advice for us rule-following, sun-worshipping cruisers who like to sleep in."
I can't imagine why she never responded! It seemed to me these were questions rich with crucial ettiquite issues into which she would have loved to dive!