Debbie, are you planning to do the Circle SA cruise in 2008? At the beginning of your WC last year, for the first few weeks I had the feeling you were miserable (well, who wouldn't be with all the rough seas and seasickness and what you had been through with the missing stuff from your luggage), but after a short time, I couldn't wait to see what adventure you were looking for next! I SO enjoyed your journals!
I think I would choose the Voyager if I had the option. I LOVE the Mariner, but I like the layout of the Voyager, especially with the VL and casino being right across the hall from each other, the the tiny extra width of cabins that allows two people to pass the bed, and better bathrooms on Voyager. Other than that, they are the same to me. Oh, maybe vibration in back cabins of Voyager would be an issue to some, but I always book as low and midship as possible for avoiding sea-sickness.