The current policy and practices sound like the best of all worlds to me. But I have to admit that I would be a MAJOR proponent of bringing the free caviar back!!
Btw, I know this is a little off topic, but...went to buy some caviar before New Years (having forgotten to order some online), and the CHEAPEST price I could find for Sevruga was $65 an oz! Rediculous -- I can order online for half that. So, no caviar for me this NYE. Oh well!