Unless there are specific ports of call

OR

you don't like sea days,

you might want to consider the Mariner from Ft Lauderdale instead of Navigator from San Juan. Air will be much cheaper and ALL Mariner cabins have balconies. If you are looking for a Jan - Apr timeframe, these are your only options. If you are possibly looking at Dec, then Voyager (ALL balconies) is also an option.

Caribbean sailings, except for a few holiday sailings, have all been 2 for 1 last couple of years. As you are SSS members, some of these sailings might have 10% or even 20% discounts on top of 2 for 1.

Bottom line: Decide on whether you are looking for specific ports or just want a Caribbean cruise. If the latter, look for the best deal on Mariner or Voyager. Navigator only comes out cheaper if you go without balcony (an option for your kids?).