We were on Turtle Island for a week in 1989, it was heaven. I'd be afraid to go back now, because I'd be afraid they had modernized it too much. When we were there, we went out fishing at night with the native Fijians, and had a kerosene lantern in the bottom of the boat for light. Every evening, a lantern was delivered to the door of our cottage (bure) because we'd need that to get to the open air dining room.
Back in those olden days, the Blue Lagoon Cruises would sail past but weren't allowed to dock. I don't know what they do now, obviously.