The only time I recall having two cabin attendants (and seeing them) was on my Navigator 2000 Alaska cruise

In my next three cruises (last one on Nov 2007) I always saw only one, and as far as I could see the cabin was always very clean and the fridge stocked. So I don't see this as a problem.

I just found out about brown water issue. I guess we were always lucky never saw any ( but I have had that problem in hotels!).