Richard, I cruise probably more than Bobbi, but for me it is not the "same cruise" if the itinerary is different each cruise, no matter the ship! We do get off the ship, after all. Other than MINT, that is why I am on the ship! If you want that "small ship" feel, I would suggest you look into Silverseas Wind and Cloud, as they are both around the same size or smaller than the Diamond and PG. I loved the Shadow (one of their larger sister ships), but it did have the "feel" of RSSC, since the ships were built at the same shipyard, and service and cabins seemed the same to me. And it has your favorite, all-inclusive!! I am not wedded to RSSC, but with my all-balcony, open dinner seating, mostly all inclusive requirements, I am pretty much limited to RSSC and SS. My former sister in law also loves Sea Dream Yacht Club, really small ships. There is a lot of competition out there among luxury ships, and they are all trying to get our business. Seabourn maybe, since you don't require a balcony, I think?