Denise,
Not to drag this on too long, but the more I think about it, I really need to "experience" a formal night before I say too much on the subject. I have only been on 2 cruises, neither one had a formal night so I may be in for a surprise on this cruise. I may love it!! But I doubt that I will think it was worth hauling half a suitcase full of clothes for just one night.
I might do a poll on formal nights after our cruise just to see who likes them and who hates them, just for fun!
Editing to say I went ahead with the poll anyway. Can't wait to see the results.