Marc, it's almost hard for me to remember our PARIS cruise on AMA. I remember how cold it was but really enjoyed seeing the Xmas markets and we had lots of fun. As for the ship itself, I don't think there's any riverboat in existence that can compare with the Crystal product. The entire ship is upscale, it's all inclusive and the best crew we've ever sailed with. I like that the maximum passengers is 104 (going by memory). It makes for a really nice, intimate experience on a gorgeous new ship. Including liquor is always a nice perk for us thought not a deal breaker.
On the other hand, AMA is nice. In 2015 we went on a Paris to Normandy cruise on AMA and it was great, no complaints whatsoever. There will likely be more AMA passengers onboard but with more passengers, they may offer a better selection of tours? We had a Queen bed on AMA which was fine for us...not as good as the king we had on Crystal.
I think you're going to have to weigh the price, number of nights, and itinerary and make your decision from there. I'm not familiar with Uniworld but cruising with Jim and Pat sounds like a great option too.