I am sailing on Oceania's Regatta June 8 to June 22 from Stockholm to London so I will have firsthand information to offer after that. Actually Claudia's positive reviews have spurred me to sail with them.
As far as tipping, they are like many lines and automatically add gratuities to your onboard account. It is $11.50 per guest per day. An additional $3.50 per day is added for Penthouse Suites and above which include butler service. If you do not agree with the amount, they have an interactive television so that you can change the amount without having to interface with anyone except the tv. I like that idea.