What a fun idea for you all. I would definitely recommend pre-ordering the turkey. On the Discovery Collection in 2008, Crystal and I had the opportunity to enjoy Thanksgiving dinner with Captain McNeill, the ship hostese and 3 other couples. All 10 of us ordered the turkey (not all Americans at the table) and it was delicious. In 2010 on DINGO, we again celebrated Thanksgivingon the Navigator to a disappointing rolled turkey.