Kristin...several fellow passengers suggested that we might like Silver Seas. I'm sure we will try them when an itinerary fits.
I don't want my comments to steer anyone away from Seabourn - it is an enjoyable experience but perhaps their hype only serves to raise expectation.
Now that Regent is "all-inclusive" I think they can give Seabourn and SilverSea a run for the money.
The nicest part of an open bar is not "free booze" but rather the chance to mix with interesting fellow passengers in the lounges.
The "insuite" liquor doesn't make that happen.
We opened one bottle of wine in our suite - left 4 other bottles unopened - didn't really care to drink alone in our cabin - it's much more fun in The Club.
It will be fun to be on the Mariner now that it's an even comparison!
Joanna....while we prefer a balcony we really didn't miss it all that much. The ship is small and you're on deck so easily when you want to be we didn't rally miss it.
We were offered an upgrade to the "french" balcony but the shower issue prevented us from accepting.
I do like to have the opportunity to open the door for some fresh air and I missed that.
When they have the new ships I think many people will give them a try, but I think at that point the size of the passenger load will make them just like everyone else - not better, no worse.