Peggy - small consolation for your troubles - but write United about your problems - I'm pretty sure they'll send you a certificate for a future flight (probably $250). The 2 people moved up to First Class probably was not random - since protocol dictates that they upgrade (complimentary) by status in an "oversold" situation (which your situation can be argued was since there were some broken seats) - they'll first upgrade Global Services, then 1K, then Premier Executive, and finally Premier in that order.