I just read one of the most thorough reviews I've ever seen; it was posted on CC (link below). It was of an August cruise to Alaska on the Shadow. I think anyone interested in Silversea would benefit by reading it.
We've only been on Silversea once (for CAMEL), and I still give the edge to Regent, but I think this review gives an excellent picture of the Silversea experience. As I posted on that thread, I only regret that apparently the author has never been on Regent, so he only mentioned some comparisons with Crystal and Seabourn. See
Shadow/Alaska Review .
Edited to add that in addition to the review, there is a second thread on CC that has extensive day-by-day reviews of his experience.
------------
Eugene