Kristin,
I believe that RSSC WILL and DOES reduce your fare if the fare comes down. I know I have received the $1000 off/or free air special when it was applied to a cruise I had already paid for in full. Since I was doing my own air a $2000 credit was applied to my credit card automatically.
As far as I know, if the fare comes down you will get the new fare, but you may lose out on an early deal if you don't book in time. I have always considered RSSC to be a win-win if you book early!!
I'm sure Ngaire will post the real deal...